Cheeseburger in Paradise Menu Prices & Delivery 2022 - Middletown NY 10940 - (845) 343-9252

Updated at July 3, 2022 by Menuiva Team

Cheeseburger in Paradise is a restaurant located at 340 Rt-211 E, Middletown, NY 10940. Cheeseburger in Paradise serves several menus including Sunset Soups & Salads, First Wave, Cheeseburgers In Paradise and Powerhouse Wings. Check out the latest price of Cheeseburger in Paradise menu and compare it with our price. Prices may change at any time, so be sure to check our prices before you order.

Sunset Soups & Salads

Choice of dressings include: Citrus vinaigrette, balsamic vinaigrette, thai chili, coconut curry, ranch, honey mustard and blue cheese

Chicken & Sausage Gumbo

A true classic made with roasted chicken and andouille sausage topped with island rice

Featured Soup

Calypso Chicken Salad

Roasted chicken, strawberries, pineapples, mandarin oranges, apples, honey roasted almonds and red onions tossed with fresh salad mix and citrus vinaigrette dressing. Substitute blackened shrimp $1.99

Buffalo Chicken Salad

Crispy buffalo chicken on top of fresh salad mix with cucumbers, celery, buffalo asiago cheese, wontons and grape tomatoes tossed in our blue cheese dressing

Chopped Wedge Salad

Applewood smoked bacon, blue cheese crumbles, grape tomatoes and Blue Cheese dressing over a chopped wedge of lettuce and drizzled with a blueberry balsamic glaze

Chopped Wedge Salad with Grilled Steak

Sailor Salad

Cucumbers, wontons, asparagus and tomatoes in a fresh salad mix tossed in our balsamic vinaigrette

Sailor Salad with Pulled Chicken

Sailor Salad with Grilled Steak

Sailor Salad with Blackened Shrimp

Thai Shrimp Salad

Crispy shrimp, fresh greens, cabbage, wontons, cucumbers, shredded carrots, honey roasted almonds, grape tomatoes, and mango tossed with choice of dressing

Citrus Salmon Salad

Citrus jalapeno glazed blackened salmon on top of fresh salad mix tossed with spinach, blue cheese crumbles, red onions, strawberries, oranges, wontons, almonds and citrus vinaigrette dressing

Costa Rican Steak Salad

Grilled sliced seasoned steak on top of fresh salad mix with roasted corn, cucumbers, red onions, wontons, salsa and blue cheese crumbles tossed with balsamic vinaigrette

First Wave

Mediterranean Shrimp

Six large pan-seared shrimp tossed in a garlic basil pesto with grape tomatoes served on grilled bread

Fried Pickles

Claussen pickle chips breaded and fried, served with a sweet horseradish dipping sauce

Four Mini-Cheeseburgers

Mini-cheeseburgers topped with cheese, pickles and caramelized onions

Pretzels in Paradise

Large hand-rolled New York pretzels lightly salted and freshly baked until golden brown. Served hot with spicy queso dip

Popcorn Shrimp

Lightly-breaded, mildly seasoned and fried, served with our asian dipping sauce. Also available buffalo style

Guacamole & Chips

Our homemade guacamole served with crispy tortilla chips

Sweet Potato Chips

Signature house-made sweet potato chips, dusted with our seasoning blend

Triple D

Chips served with choice of three great dips. Choose from crab and spinach dip, spicy queso, homemade guacamole or salsa

Spicy Queso & Chips

Our spicy cheese dip blends cheddar and asiago cheeses with tomatoes and seasoning. Served with crispy tortilla chips and a side of salsa

Crab & Spinach Dip

Lump crab meat mixed with spinach and asiago cheese. Served with crispy tortilla chips

Onion Six-Strings

Thinly-sliced onions, breaded and fried, then lightly seasoned. Served with our asian dipping sauce

Smugglers' Platter

Our three most popular appetizers on one plate, mini-cheeseburgers, dragon fire chicken wings and fried pickles

Ten Mini-Cheeseburgers

Mini-cheeseburgers topped with cheese, pickles and caramelized onions

Cheeseburgers in Paradise

Our burgers are 100% USDA choice ground chuck, served on our house or wheat bun. All burgers are served with french fried potatoes. Side of spicy queso dipping sauce $0.99

Bacon Cheddar Burger

Cheddar cheese, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, red onion, pickles and mayo

Guacamole Bacon Burger

Pepper jack cheese, applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato and topped with homemade guacamole. Served on an onion ciabatta roll

Mushroom Swiss Burger

Crimini mushrooms, swiss cheese, fried onion strings, asian mayo and lettuce

Patty Melt

Traditional patty melt with swiss cheese and caramelized onions, served on toasted rye bread

Baja Burger

Sour cream, shredded lettuce, jalapenos, onions, pepper jack cheese and salsa

BBQ Cheddar Burger

Cheddar cheese, BBQ sauce, pickles, lettuce and fried onion strings

Good Egg Burger

American cheese, grilled ham, over-easy fried egg and mayo

Powerhouse Burger

The great flavor from our buffalo wings on a burger buffalo asiago cheese, hot wing sauce, blue cheese dressing, tomato, red onion and lettuce

Turkey Burger

Veggie Burger


Four mini-cheeseburgers topped with cheese, pickles and caramelized onions

Oh So Gouda Burger

Gouda cheese, sauteed crimini mushrooms, fried basil, caramelized onions and roasted red pepper basil sauce served on an onion ciabatta roll

Chesapeake Bay Burger

Mixture of lump crab meat, spinach, cheddar, monterey jack and asiago cheeses on top of a burger with lettuce and a touch of old bay seasoning

Pressed Burger

Velveeta cheese, salsa ketchup, pickles and mayo, pressed until golden brown

Beach Burger

American cheese, pickles, lettuce, red onion and tomato, with a big kosher dill pickle on the side

Back to Basics Burger

Add choice of cheese $0.99. Add lettuce, tomato, onion and pickle $0.99

Burger of the Day

Featured daily burger

Powerhouse Wings

These wings are a powerhouse of flavor. Always fresh, never frozen, hand breaded to order and tossed in your choice of delicious sauce. All wings are served with celery and choice of blue cheese or ranch

Eighteen Traditional Wings

Boneless Wings

Crispy boneless all white meat chicken strips tossed in any of our signature sauces

Ten Traditional Wings


Kung Pow

These wings have a sweet and spicy kick try this flavorful blend of thai chili and sweetened garlic teriyaki

Hot Garlic Buffalo

Spicy buffalo and buttery garlic


Back by popular demand the tango with our mango in a unique blend of sweet and savory goodness


With this sweet asian blend


A taste of the south with these birds

Dragon Fire

Our most popular sauce is made with sweet thai chili


This jerk is made with traditional caribbean spices

Citrus Jalapeno

Sweet at times but with a wild side. Ours is a blend of citrus with a kick of jalapeno


One hot chick traditional buffalo with a kick

Ginger Garlic

With this sweet aromatic blend of ginger and garlic

Thai Peanut

Exotic thai peanut sauce creates an irresistible flavor

Hell Fire

Our buffalo sauce fired up with habanero peppers

Surfside Sandwiches & Wraps

All Sandwiches and wraps are served with sweet potato chips

Sweet Fire Chicken Sandwich

Blackened chicken breast with Pepper Jack cheese, dragon fire sauce, banana peppers, red onion and lettuce on an onion ciabatta roll

BBQ Chicken Sandwich

BBQ grilled chicken breast served on a wheat bun with applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese, pickles, lettuce and red onions

Fish Sandwich

Grilled or blackened tilapia with tartar sauce, shredded lettuce, tomato and red onion

Killer Crab Minis

A trio of caribbean-style crab cakes served on toasted buns with red pepper aioli sauce and shredded lettuce

El Cubano

Ham, salami, pork, swiss cheese, mayo, mustard and pickles pressed until golden brown

Jerk Chicken Wrap

Fried jerk chicken strips, lettuce, salsa, chopped applewood smoked bacon, red onions, cheddar and jack cheeses in a tomato basil tortilla

Costa Rican Steak Wrap

Grilled seasoned steak, swiss cheese, roasted peppers, crimini mushrooms, salsa and balsamic onions in a tomato basil tortilla

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Crispy buffalo chicken with shredded lettuce, buffalo asiago cheese, cucumbers and blue cheese dressing in a tomato basil tortilla

Turkey Avocado Wrap

Turkey, avocado, applewood smoked bacon, pepper jack cheese, lettuce, ranch and salsa in a tomato basil tortilla

Molly's Club

Oven roasted turkey breast, ham, applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato and mayo served on wheat-berry toast

Paradise Specialties

Tropical Chicken Satay

Marinated chicken skewers, grilled and served with coconut curry dipping sauce and choice of side

St. Barts Citrus Chicken

Citrus marinated chicken breasts seasoned, grilled and served over Island rice with teriyaki broccoli

Coastal Shrimp

Sauteed shrimp tossed in a light chardonnay cream sauce, crimini mushrooms, sun-dried tomatoes, fresh spinach and penne pasta. Served with garlic bread

Fish and Chips

Crispy hand-battered fish, lightly seasoned and served with french fried potatoes

Fish Tacos

Three flour tortillas stuffed with choice of grilled or fried fish, crisp cabbage blend and fresh pineapple salsa. Drizzled with avocado cream and served with island rice

Shrimp Tacos

Three flour tortillas stuffed with blackened shrimp, crisp cabbage blend and fresh pineapple salsa. Drizzled with avocado cream and served with island rice

BBQ Ribs

Slow-cooked, marinated and seasoned babyback pork ribs basted with BBQ sauce. Served with choice of side

Island Quesadilla

Pulled chicken, cheddar and Jack cheeses, crimini mushrooms, balsamic onions, roasted peppers and chopped applewood smoked bacon. Drizzled with avocado cream and served with choice of side

Coconut Shrimp

Large, crispy, beer-battered shrimp hand rolled with our coconut breading, served with a pina colada dipping sauce and french fried potatoes

Parrot Beach Salmon

Grilled salmon prepared with choice of kingston Jerk with fresh pineapple salsa, teriyaki or BBQ sauce. Served over Island rice with teriyaki broccoli

Additional Sides

Sweet Potato Chips

Teriyaki Broccoli

Island Rice

French Fried Potatoes

Vegetable of the Day


Little Parakeets

For children under 10. Includes a choice of the following beverages: Soda, milk or our fresh parakeet punch and a choice of the following sides: French fried potatoes, teriyaki broccoli or mandarin oranges


BBQ Ribs

Flame Grilled Steak

Cheese Quesadilla

Chicken Quesadilla

Corn Dogs

Chicken Fingers

Mac 'N Cheese

Grilled Chicken Breast

Lil' Pirates Treat

Choice of vanilla, strawberry or chocolate blue bell, ice cream topped with chocolate sauce, sprinkles and oreo, cookie crumbles

Sensuous Treats

Chocolate Nachos

Chocolate and flour tortillas fried, sweetened and covered with chocolate sauce, strawberries and colored sprinkles. Served with blue bell, strawberry and vanilla ice cream for dipping

Copa Ban

Fresh bananas, strawberries, toasted coconut, whipped cream, nilla, wafers and banana pudding layered in our martini glass

Key Lime Pie

A delicious recipe from the florida keys, topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut

Jamaican Apple Crisp

Warm caramelized granny smith apples with a touch of ginger and cinnamon abundantly covered with crisp granola walnut crumbs and topped with blue bell, vanilla ice cream

Cocoa Rica Cake

Layers of rich chocolate cake frosted with chocolate icing topped with seasonal fruit and whipped cream. Add a scoop of blue bell, vanilla ice cream $0.99

Non-Alcoholic Beverages

Hand-Dipped Milkshakes

Our homemade hand-dipped shakes are made with blue bell, ice cream. Choose from the following flavors: vanilla, chocolate, strawberry or oreo

Island Paradise

Pineapple and coconut are complemented with pomegranate grenadine and a splash of sprite

Jamaican Root Beer Float

Our caribbean version of a root beer float. blue bell, vanilla ice cream, coconut flavor and barq's, root beer

Surfside Sodas

Mixture of fresca and choice of ruby red grapefruit, pomegranate, or peach flavor

Flavored Iced Tea - Peach



Raspberry and Blueberry

Strawberry Lemonade

Bottled Water

Island Lemonade

Lemonade Iced Tea

Red Bull

Freshly Brewed Coffee


DISCLAIMER: Please be aware that the information on this website may not be up-to-date. For the most up-to-date pricing and menu, please contact the restaurant directly.

Random Menus for You

Cheeseburger in Paradise

340 Rt-211 E, Middletown, NY 10940
(845) 343-9252

© 2021 All rights reserved. Also loved Indonesian Culinary Menu.